|||

When the Cloud Falls, It Lands on Us

The collapse of AI hype won’t free us. It’ll bury us.

There’s a persistent fantasy among reformers that when the generative AI bubble pops, we’ll be left with a surplus of infrastructure we can reclaim. Data centers. GPUs. Purpose-built tooling. The thinking goes: if Big Tech falls, maybe we can use their scraps to build something useful.

But that’s not how collapse works. The cloud won’t fall into our hands. It will fall into the waiting arms of the carceral state, the defense industry, the surveillance supply chain.

When AIs promises no longer attract capital, they’ll attract procurement. Inference pipelines won’t be mothballed, they’ll be nationalized. Whatever isn’t privatized will be securitized. The data centers will hum. The tooling will stay. The models will be repurposed for compliance, for borders, for predictive profiling.

We will be told it’s pragmatic. That it’s better for these tools to serve government than disappear entirely. That they’ve already been built, so we might as well use them. But use” in this context means control. It means surveillance. It means digitized punishment.

This is not the end of AI. It is the end of illusions about what happens next.

Collapse does not create voids. It creates vacuums. And power rushes in.

There will be no civic reclamation of AIs ruins. Not without a fight. Not without a fundamental rethinking of what infrastructure is for and who it serves. Because this was never just about automation. It was about legitimacy. Bureaucratic authority. The performance of order.

And when it lands, it won’t be on the billionaires who built it. It will land, as it always does, on the people least protected by the systems it was sold to replace.

Drafted while listening to Ryuichi Sakamoto — Solari

Up next Not a Roadmap There’s something familiar about this time of year. Maybe it’s the flood of trend decks. Maybe it’s the breathless declarations that we’ve turned My personal rant about platform decay
Latest posts Ranking the Unrankable: Building a Better System for Oregon High School Tennis On the Simulation of Governance My personal rant about platform decay When the Cloud Falls, It Lands on Us Not a Roadmap When User Experience (UX) no longer explains the work: Interaction Engineering as concept Libraries Weren’t the Point: Fiscal Archetypes for Speculative Civics The Interface Is The Interview Civic Tech, Local Impact: Launching the Portland Digital Corps On Doing What You Can The Interface Trap: How Administrative Systems Create Unsolvable Problems Context-Aware Agents: Designing for Alignment in AX Some thoughts on hiring, quality & public service Notes on Modernization and System Change Why would you take a promotion without a raise? Service Design for AI: Why Human Experience (HX) Matters On adapting my coaching philosophy Writing about personal stuff On Goals & Invisible Lines On Secret Hobbies (or About My First Talk of 2025) On Resolutions From Tools to Territory: How Systems Become Infrastructure On Lasting Resilience Scoring Baseball’s Golden At-Bat: Why Finland’s Pesäpallo Already Has a Better Solution Dismantling Things Takes Time What I’ve learned about posting in a post-Twitter world Rushing into the elevator to avoid saying hello Wrote about that one time I was a game designer On AI and Care On House Rules Robbed of thoughts